Welcome,
Guest
. Please
login
or
register
.
Did you miss your
activation email
?
December 09, 2019, 03:02:49 PM
Don't forget to check if your profile email address is up to date.
Home
Forum
Search
Members Map
Photos Gallery
FAQ's
Login
Register
Tiger Explorer
»
Bikers Chat
»
On Two Wheels
»
Is a V3 possible?
« previous
next »
Print
Pages:
1
[
2
]
3
Go Down
Author
Topic: Is a V3 possible? (Read 2892 times)
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
Dilbert
Explorer Pro
Posts: 475
Bike: 2019 Tiger 800 XRx
City / Town: Holmes Chapel
Country: UK
Re: Is a V3 possible?
«
Reply #10 on:
September 26, 2018, 12:47:24 PM »
V engines in bikes are normally only V-twins, in cars they're V6, V8, or V12, the reason for being an equal number is that it helps balancing the piston thrust, across the frame V-twins, where the cylinders stick out either side (e.g. Moto Guzzi) are known for vibrations as the engine fires one way, then the other, akin to the BMW Boxer engine, in-line V-twins (e.g. Ducati) are better and don't make the bike jump from side to side
Making an unequal number V engine can be done, but you end up with all sorts of issues with balancing rotors and weights, the Boxer engines employ a large flywheel in an attempt to smooth this out, the Honda V5 used five smaller pistons, with the V inline, but three cylinders at the front and two at the rear, I believe the main reason for this configuration was for cooling efficiency i.e. not having three cylinders hidden behind the front three and to make the engine narrower with the con-rods evenly spaced, but it's just easier to stick with twins, triple and fours in a "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" kind of logic
There have been some successful V4 bike engines, especially the Honda VFR's
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/V4_engine
, but relatively few have had success with a V3 (Honda NS500 being the exception)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/V3_engine
Logged
I'll never be old enough to know better !
PTwizz
Explorer Member
Posts: 38
Bike: Tiger1200XC2015
City / Town: Norfolk
Country: United Kingdom
Re: Is a V3 possible?
«
Reply #11 on:
September 26, 2018, 01:42:52 PM »
Originally Posted by
Dilbert
... it's just easier to stick with twins, triple and fours in a "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" kind of logic
For much of my motorcycling life, inline fours were widely considered to be that which wasn't broke and didn't need fixing. Then Triumph came along with their crackpot idea to make inline triples work properly.
There's no reason why a V3 couldn't be made to work just as well as an inline 3 or a V4 or any other layout.
The question is, what is the advantage of a V3? It is argued that the inline 3 has a favourable mix of torque and power which is well suited to motorcycles. It also offers a narrower package than an inline 4 so it can be argued that it is a 'better' motorcycle engine.
Does the OP propose that a V3 offers any advantage over other configurations?
Logged
Tigraid
Explorer Member
Posts: 91
Bike: '16 R1200GSA
City / Town: Dursley
Country: United Kingdom
Re: Is a V3 possible?
«
Reply #12 on:
October 01, 2018, 10:34:26 AM »
Speaking as an engineer, I cannot see any reason for a V3 over an inline 3 or a V twin or V4. As mentioned, all it would bring is complications, extra weight for no real benefit. It would likely not be any lighter than a well designed V4.
Triumph's triple differs from other IL4 engines not just because it uses 3 instead of 4 cylinders, but because the firing order of the crank means almost optimal torque delivery characteristics from its 120 degree firing order. Combined with the ability to deliver torque low down where it is needed and to rev high up smoothly for power, it has formed the basis of several successful racing engines not to mention the big adventure bikes that we run around on. The fact that Moto2 has just employed Triumph (765) triples is testament to the success of their middleweight IL3 designs.
The benefit of a Vee4 over an IL3 it could be argued is mass centralisation and lower C of G, which is presumably (along with favoured power characteristics) is one reason that the racing world employs them. There's ways and means to lower C of G for an IL3 but unfortunately where high ground clearance is concerned (adventure bikes again) not possible without significant compromises to wheelbase and handling characteristics.
Personally, I prefer the power delivery of an IL3 for the road over most other multis, but also like Vee twins and boxers.
Logged
Dilbert
Explorer Pro
Posts: 475
Bike: 2019 Tiger 800 XRx
City / Town: Holmes Chapel
Country: UK
Re: Is a V3 possible?
«
Reply #13 on:
October 02, 2018, 12:39:10 PM »
Speaking as another (Mechanical) engineer, though not in automotive, I largely agree with Tigraid, traditionally the advantage of a V-engine over an inline has been the additional low down torque, this is the same as in the Boxer engine, something to do with opposing, or partly opposing pistons, I'm too old to remember why exactly, it just is
Logged
I'll never be old enough to know better !
PTwizz
Explorer Member
Posts: 38
Bike: Tiger1200XC2015
City / Town: Norfolk
Country: United Kingdom
Re: Is a V3 possible?
«
Reply #14 on:
October 02, 2018, 12:57:51 PM »
One advantage of the V configuration is the packaging. A V engine is shorter than an inline for the same number and size of cylinders. It also has a shorter and therefore stiffer crankshaft. The logical extension of the concept is the radial engine, which uses a single throw crank with multiple cylinders, providing huge quantities of smooth, low rpm torque.
They don't package so well in a bike.
Logged
Griff
Explorer God
Posts: 3114
Bike: Explorer and others
City / Town: Wicklow
Country: Ireland
Re: Is a V3 possible?
«
Reply #15 on:
October 03, 2018, 11:02:31 AM »
It makes no sense really because surely the crank length will be the same as an inline 3 and a cylinder out of line with the others will only cause intake and exhaust plumbing issues that are not relevant to the inline motor.
Logged
PTwizz
Explorer Member
Posts: 38
Bike: Tiger1200XC2015
City / Town: Norfolk
Country: United Kingdom
Re: Is a V3 possible?
«
Reply #16 on:
October 03, 2018, 11:22:55 AM »
It depends on what we think of as a V3.
If the configuration is one bank of 2 cylinders and a second bank of 1 cylinder, then the crank can be shorter than an inline 3.
If the configuration is a double V, like the Anzani, then the crank may be a single throw.
What is the designer trying to achieve? As with any design, there are a series of compromises to be made between packaging, performance, cost, etc.
So the answer to the OP's question is Yes, a V3 is possible. The next question is: What do you expect to achieve by it?
Logged
CaptainTrips
Explorer God
Posts: 4535
Bike: '13 Explorer
City / Town: Vancouver(ish)
Country: CA
Re: Is a V3 possible?
«
Reply #17 on:
October 03, 2018, 04:54:30 PM »
The way I envision this, a V3 would have six separate camshafts with three separate cam chain drives. That's got to add some weight and complexity. Imagine having to deal with 3 separate chain tensioners instead of one.
Logged
"The test of the machine is the satisfaction it gives you. There isn't any other test."
-- Robert M. Pirsig
NiK
Explorer God
Posts: 4347
Bike: Red Skin Mk3
City / Town: Marseille
Country: France
Re: Is a V3 possible?
«
Reply #18 on:
October 03, 2018, 05:03:39 PM »
Originally Posted by
CaptainTrips
The way I envision this, a V3 would have six separate camshafts with three separate cam chain drives. That's got to add some weight and complexity. Imagine having to deal with 3 separate chain tensioners instead of one.
Maybe time to go back to the outstandingly reliable timing gears that Honda implemented on the VFR?
Logged
PTwizz
Explorer Member
Posts: 38
Bike: Tiger1200XC2015
City / Town: Norfolk
Country: United Kingdom
Re: Is a V3 possible?
«
Reply #19 on:
October 03, 2018, 05:08:42 PM »
...or pushrods.
Logged
Print
Pages:
1
[
2
]
3
Go Up
« previous
next »
Tiger Explorer
»
Bikers Chat
»
On Two Wheels
»
Is a V3 possible?
Recent Topics
It's goodbye from me...
[
Tiger Explorer - General Discussion
]
redmerle
Today
at 02:51:12 PM
Max Miles: How many miles on your Tiger 1200's?
[
On Two Wheels
]
redmerle
Today
at 02:36:34 PM
Your favourite local motorcycling cafe
[
On Two Wheels
]
redmerle
Today
at 02:30:04 PM
Screens
[
Accessories and Products
]
Dark Star
Today
at 02:12:56 PM
No tire pressure sensors on the new on... why did they remove it?
[
Tiger Explorer - General Discussion
]
T800XC
Today
at 09:34:19 AM
Just a reminder about a great supplier I used for Gen 1 upgrade parts.
[
Accessories and Products
]
NiK
Today
at 09:25:48 AM
TFT display options
[
Tiger Explorer - General Discussion
]
NiK
Today
at 09:06:57 AM
The "My Triumph's not broken & working well" thread.
[
On Two Wheels
]
redmerle
Yesterday
at 04:03:48 PM
Sale
[
Parts, Accessories & Clothing For Sale
]
redmerle
Yesterday
at 01:43:27 PM
Arrow exhaust for Gen1
[
Accessories and Products
]
redmerle
December 07, 2019, 05:20:13 PM
nonskid